Research links mental distress to significantly increased risk of death in heart patients
A team including Auckland City Hospital cardiologist Professor Ralph Stewart has shown persistent, moderate-to-severe mental distress is linked to a significantly heightened risk of death among patients with stable coronary heart disease.
Professor Stewart says no such association was found for those experiencing persistent mild or occasional distress over the long term.
Many studies have linked anxiety/depression with an increased risk of heart attack/stroke, but these have mostly been done fairly soon after the event, and based on a single assessment, say the researchers. And the definitions of chronic/persistent stress in other longer term studies have varied widely.
In a bid to get round some of these issues an international team of researchers, an investigation initiated by Professor Stewart, looked at the association between occasional or persistent mental distress and the risk of death in 950 people aged between 31 and 74 with stable coronary heart disease.
All the participants were part of the Long Term Intervention with Pravastatin in Ischaemic Disease Trial and had had a heart attack or been admitted to hospital for unstable angina in the preceding three to 36 months.
They filled in a validated general health questionnaire (GHQ30) at six months, 1, 2, and 4 years after the event to gauge their levels of mental distress.
This was graded according to severity and length of time it lasted at each of the assessments: never distressed; occasional (of any severity); persistent mild distress on three or more occasions; and persistent moderate distress on three or more occasions. The participants’ health and survival were then tracked for an average of 12 years.
During the monitoring period, 398 people died from all causes and 199 died from cardiovascular disease.
The questionnaire responses showed that 587 (62%) of participants said they had not been distressed at any of the assessments, while around one in four (27%) said they had experienced occasional distress of any severity.
Around one in 10 (8%) said they had experienced persistent mild distress, and 35 people (3.7%) complained of persistent moderate distress.
People in this last group were nearly four times as likely to have died of cardiovascular disease and nearly three times as likely to have died from any cause as those who said they had not been distressed at any of the assessments.
No such associations were observed for those who said they had experienced persistent mild distress or those who said they had only experienced it occasionally.
The findings held true even after taking account of other potentially influential risk factors.
This is an observational study, so no firm conclusions can be drawn about cause and effect, added to which confining the assessments to a period of four years might have underestimated the true impact of persistent distress, caution the researchers.
Nevertheless, they conclude that the increase in risk of death was “substantial.” And they go on to say: “These findings suggest that in patients with stable [coronary heart disease], long term mortality risk is related to the cumulative burden of psychological distress.”
In a linked editorial in the latest issue of the journal Heart, Dr Gjin Ndrepepa of the Technical University, Munich, Germany, points out that the GHQ-30 is no longer widely used and highlights that the researchers did not account for the impact of traumatic life events or socioeconomic factors.
But he adds that mental distress activates the sympathetic nervous system and boosts stress hormone levels, which, if persistent, can produce potentially harmful physiological changes, some of which may be permanent. Distress can also prompt unhealthy behaviours.
“The possibility is real that [coronary heart disease] itself is the source of distress and a determinant of poor outcome,” he writes, adding that health professionals should include screening for mental distress a routine part of the care provided to patients with coronary heart disease.
For interviews with Professor Stewart or media enquiries regarding Auckland DHB, please contact the Auckland DHB Communications Department (09 375 3499 or email firstname.lastname@example.org). The research can be viewed here (external link) .
Last modified:← Back to the news